
Guides · Compared
Imposter game vs Mafia vs Werewolf
The short answer
All three are hidden-role games where a few players lie and the table votes. Mafia and Werewolf need a moderator, run for 20 minutes or more and suit 8 players and up. The imposter word game needs no moderator, plays in a few minutes from 3 players, and nobody sits out. Pick by group size and how long you have.
How are they different?
| Imposter word game | Mafia | Werewolf | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Players | 3 to 10 | About 7 and up | About 8 and up |
| Moderator | No (the app or the cards deal) | Yes | Yes |
| The secret | A word everyone knows but the impostor | Who the mafia are | Who the werewolves are |
| Elimination | No, everyone plays every round | Yes, players are knocked out | Yes, players are knocked out |
| One game | A few minutes per round | 20 minutes or more | 20 minutes or more |
| Equipment | One iPhone, or paper | None, cards optional | Role cards |
When is Mafia or Werewolf the better choice?
With 10 people or more, one long game of Mafia builds alliances, grudges and big reveals that short rounds cannot. Werewolf adds special roles, a seer or a healer for example, for groups who like more moving parts. If someone loves narrating, give them the moderator seat: a good moderator makes the game.
When is the imposter game the better choice?
With 3 to 8 people, little time, or a mixed table of regulars and first-timers. Every round takes a few minutes, everyone plays every round, and nobody has to run the game. One clue is enough to give the impostor away, so it rewards listening more than arguing loudly.
In Masked Impostor, the iPhone deals the cards, keeps the timer and the score, and at the verdict the caught impostor gets one last chance to guess the word and steal the round. Rules are in how to play the imposter game.
How do you play Mafia, in short?
- The moderator secretly gives each player a role: a few mafia, the rest townspeople.
- Night: everyone closes their eyes; the mafia open theirs and silently pick a victim.
- Day: the moderator announces who was hit, the town debates and votes someone out.
- The town wins when every mafia member is out; the mafia wins when they equal the town.
Can you mix them in one evening?
Yes, and it works well: warm up with a few imposter rounds while people arrive, then switch to Mafia once the whole group is there. For other ideas, see the best party word games and games like Among Us you can play in person.
Questions people ask
- Is Werewolf the same as Mafia?
- Almost: Werewolf is Mafia set in a village, and many versions add special roles such as a seer.
- Do you need a moderator for the imposter game?
- No. The app, or a shuffled set of printed cards, deals the roles, so everyone can play.
- Which is best for a small group?
- The imposter word game: it plays from 3 players, while Mafia needs about 7.
About this guide
Written by Benjamin Mongin, who designed and built Masked Impostor. The rules, settings and word pairs on this page come straight from the app; the tips come from playing it at the table. Other games are named only to compare them; their names belong to their publishers.